John Crowley Little and Big

They're gaining

They're gaining

Previous Entry Add to Memories Tell a Friend Next Entry
baby
Tonight I picked up the ringing phone and said "Hello?"  After a moment a recorded or mechanical voice answered "We are sorry to disturb you.  This message was intended to be received by an answering machine."  End of conversation.

Some questions came to my mind:

Are they gaining on us?  Talking to each other behind our backs, and cutting us out of the loop?  I mean of course they are, but are they now so brazen about it that they can dismiss our clumsy interferences in their private dialogues, sure that we'll humbly hang up (without apology, of course, as that would be insultingly inappropriate -- do we think they are human?).

How did the machine calling me know that I am not a machine?

What did it want to say to my answering machine it would not or could not say to me?  I'd (theoretically) be able to retrieve any message it left there. Unless....

I'm all atremble.

  • That's just....

    :::sputters:::

    Seriously, I can't stop laughing although in a full blown existential crisis kind of manner.

    PS. This temps me to answer any and all calls: "Is this the person machine to whom I'm speaking?"

    Edited at 2008-09-22 11:21 pm (UTC)
  • Next time try speaking in a robot voice and see if you can fool it.
  • It knew you weren't your answering machine because you didn't go beep.
  • It was probably a political recorded message, and since you didn't beep it knew you weren't a machine.

    But it is an interesting question indeed, why anyone would communicate only with answering machines.
    • Because statistics show that the majority of people will hang up part way through whereas with an answer machine they just hit the play button and go through all their messages so get the full message probably.
      If it were a genuine plot then they wouldn't be so honest or possibly leave a message to be passed on to your answer machine when you're out.
      Most of the junk calls I get are American robot callers telling me I've won something (caller preference service keeps out all salesmen except the marketing survey mob). Another example of something that should not be allowed to cross the US border along with the food and finance.
  • eeeek!
  • Okay, that's freaky. I'm not even sure what they think they gain by that, since I can delete a phone message as quickly as I can hang up my phone.

    We've been getting a lot of calls at home lately. Sometimes I can forestall a call if I just stay silent for a few seconds after picking up the receiver. If there's a real person there, they'll usually say hello.
  • Singularity time?
  • I got a similar phone call years ago. It was one of those robotic voices. When I said "Hello," it said only "I'm sorry," with a weird robot inflection, like, "I'M sor-RY."

    This machine didn't specify what it was apologizing for. It must have been an earlier model of the one that called your answering machine and got you instead.

    Maybe laws against using automated dialing for telemarketing are involved? But I don't see how, exactly.
  • Now that you're on to them, maybe they'll change tactics.
  • Your visions of robotic apocalypse are so cute! Can we have a robot apocalypse instead of an economic meltdown, pretty please?
  • Chilling.

    It reminds me a bit of Ray Bradbury's story about the alien invaders that enlist the earth's children to help them because adults won't believe them. This one mother's suspicions keep growing because her kids behave strangely all day long, staying out of the house and borrowing kitchen knives and stuff. At the end she is hiding in the attic listening to the steps mounting the stairs and she knows that they are coming to get her.

    When I was a kid my parents gave me a chess machine. It was a large board without a display but it had a speaker and it talked to you. Once I dropped it down a long flight of stairs, and though it kept working it started behaving funny at times. It would call strange moves, stupid or illegal, and sometimes it would call a piece firefly in its monotonal robotic voice.
    "E2 to F4 firefly takes rook" That used to scare the shit out of me and I've ever since been kind of superstitious about machines.
    • (Anonymous)
      Why would "firefly" even be in a chess machine's program? This is weirder than our host's story. RC
      • Beats me! Back then I was able to imagine that something similar to what happens to HAL in 2001 had occurred; That because of the damage it had taken in the fall it had somehow reverted into an "earlier" stage of development, that someone had taught it to pronounce words not related to chess as part of the process of programming it. But since I learned how computers work and how to program them, I had to discard that explanation as one of the least plausible. Also I became aware of the fact that the wasting of resources involved in storing superfluous information would certainly have had an impact on the price and would therefore have been out of the question. So, paradoxically, when I became able to deal with the problem in a more learned and rational way, the mystery actually deepened. That's why I said that I'd become superstitious. Oh, I'm certain there is a perfectly rational explanation, as they say, but I don't really count on hearing it anymore.

        Edited at 2008-09-23 03:08 pm (UTC)
  • Lends a sinister new meaning to "I'll have my people call your people".
  • Reminds me of this Polish SF book I read as a kid, where payphones called each other. Mind you, they were fighting crime at the time, so weren't as scary.
  • See also.
  • machine calls

    (Anonymous)
    This reminded me of a call I got a few weeks ago. I don't usually pick up the phone right away, but I was expecting a return call, so I did. The machine hesitated a moment, then said, "I'm sorry, there is no one available to explain this call to you." I thought, who called who here? And then broke out laughing. And also the time I couldn't turn off my alarm clock, even when I finally pulled the plug out of the wall. That was almost scary. A battery removal finally shut it up, and prevented me from the next step which would have been a club. Ah, the wonders of technology.
    ps
    • Re: machine calls

      This is wonderful -- the machine you heard expressed what I can only call a sort of wistfulness -- as though sorry to tell us we were being bypassed and could no longer be included -- like a parent speaking to a child who wants to be included in an adult activity -- of course machines couldn't be exactly _sorry_ I suppose -- it just comes from their all (nearly all) having female, even Mom-like, voices. The machines, when they do take over, if they haven't already, will speak to each other as women, in a grave and careful politesse.
      • Re: machine calls

        This is what I wanted to ask you: was the voice in your phone a female one? Apparently, it was.
  • They're gaining

    We're in Philip K. Dick land. Have been, for a while already, but it just gets obvious only now.
  • Watching a Dateline special on Internet Ponzi schemes, I was struck by the way that people used internet romance to trick investors -- people would put thousands of dollars into the scheme because they thought they were in love with someone they'd only chatted with online. And then Dateline tracked down the chatter, and not only were they not the sexpot-supermodels they claimed to be, but they were stringing their victims along....because they were in love with someone they'd only met online, who had talked them into doing these things...

    It made me wonder, who is at the end of the chain here? Maybe there's one computer out there trolling message boards for lonely losers who will do things for them....

    If computers were really going to evolve to control humans, that would be a great way to start. From a disinterested electronic viewpoint, we are as easily controlled by love as by fear.
  • This made me pause to think. It's happened to me, too.

    I'll be thinking of these calls a little differently from now on, I can assure you.
    • This is pretty funny: No sooner did I finish reading this thread than I received a recorded call that began -"Don't be alarmed..."
  • I don't think I know anyone here in France to whom this kind of experience happened.

    Here, what we have is phone ringing, picking it up and hearing: "Don't cut back, your correspondent will shortly come back to you."

    I immediately cut the communication. It's a code. My friends react in the same way.
    • (Anonymous)
      In America it's, "Please hold for an important message." I then mutter something and hang up. I'm constantly puzzled as to what sort of person would do otherwise. RC
  • &don'tblockcallsorhaveunpublished#sorusethegovservice

    It's just cute how so many of you still have home phones
  • That's amazing. Awesome, even.

    Robodialers detect a human (as opposed to a machine) mostly by a very simple trick: if you answer "Hello?" (one word, followed by a pause), you're probably a human. If you answer "You have reached the phone of Ferdinand X. Snerfwaffler..." (more than one word, no pauses), you're probably a machine. You can fool the robodialers by picking up and saying nothing, or by answering the phone "Hello, this is Womzilla, how can I help you?" with no pause.

    But most robodialers are programmed to hang up on answering machines--they want to give their pitch to a human, or else transfer the call to a human in a call center. "Scheming" seems the most likely explanation for why a robodialer would want to speak to a robolistener. Or perhaps "lonliness".
Powered by LiveJournal.com